You may have seen content floating around the internet claiming that January 1st isn’t the real New Year—that the true beginning of the year happens in the spring, once winter has fully ended. As always, opinions get strong, and people can be quick to tell others they’re “doing it wrong” by celebrating a New Year in the middle of winter.
My take? They’re both right.
For years, I’ve talked (sometimes in circles) about what I often call “nature’s New Year,” which arrives at the spring equinox. This moment marks the end of winter and the beginning of the spring season—a visible return of light, growth, and movement. In astrology, this is the reset of the zodiac cycle, with Aries as the first sign. In The Women’s Wheel of Life (my favorite!), this point on the wheel represents birth and the beginning of a new cycle. Many cultures around the world also celebrate their New Year at times other than January 1st. When you look at it this way, it’s easy to understand the argument that the “New Year” hasn’t quite arrived yet.
And…
We can also acknowledge the way our society structures time and recognize that January 1st still holds meaning. The turning of the calendar year does feel significant for many people, and that matters. Traditions, memories, and collective rituals are powerful, especially for those who grew up honoring this moment as a fresh start.
So yes, while we are still in the heart of winter when the calendar year changes, that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t celebrate New Year’s Day. As with everything in life, I always come back to one question: What feels right for you?
Does staying up late with lights, sparkle, and celebration feel like a beautiful way to honor midwinter and the closing of Yule? Wonderful.
Does setting intentions and making meaningful changes feel more aligned with the energy of the spring equinox? Amazing.
There is no single “right” way to practice ritual. There is no one correct tradition. You get to decide what resonates—and you don’t have to choose just one.
For me, I love honoring January 1st with the “13 Wishes” ritual I’ve shared before. It feels like a gentle way to look ahead and begin noticing what wants to shift. At the same time, I still feel a deep pull toward hibernation throughout January. I’m not quite ready to take bold action yet, and that feels right. I prefer to honor both milestones—the reflection of winter and the preparation for change—while slowly turning toward the year ahead.
Maybe you do too. Or maybe your experience of the New Year looks completely different.
And that, truly, is exactly how it should be.
xo,
April & Lena